We are posting a rebuttal to a recent post written here on OC Political. The rebuttal comes from Lincoln Club member David Bahnsen who originally posted the piece on his blog. In the interest of full disclosure I am a member of the Lincoln Club of Orange County.
The Lincoln Club Endorses Robert Ming: The Right Thing Done in the Right Way
Matt Cunningham has posted a bizarre piece over at OCPolitical expressing his dismay at the Lincoln Club’s decision to endorse Robert Ming for the OC Supervisor’s seat in the 5th District. It is bizarre because Matt expresses a long-held admiration for the club, and then says he has never “been more disappointed in one of the club’s actions than its endorsement of Robert Ming”. He later in the article says it is not about Robert Ming, but about the process by which the club gave the endorsement. A few comments are in order.
Matt is not a member of the Lincoln Club, and to my knowledge never has been. He is certainly not in the club’s leadership, was not at the board meeting in question, and is not in any position to know or understand what the club did, or what its policies and protocols are. He is welcome to endorse Frank Ury, and he is welcome to work for that candidate’s campaign (though I do not know if he does or not). Everyone is entitled to their own opinions, but not their own facts.
The Lincoln Club is free to endorse who it wants, when it wants, and it is not accountable to political bloggers or political consultants. In fact, we would be happier if political consultants were ALWAYS upset with what we were doing, for surely it would mean our cause would be righteous. But I digress … The club, is, however, accountable to its own bylaws. In this case, the club went above and beyond the call of duty in fidelity to our own rules and regulations. Our Executive Committee met prior to the board’s consideration of an endorsement and unanimously voted, on the merits, to endorse Robert Ming in the Supervisor’s race. The club requires a 75% super-majority of its Board of Directors to endorse a Republican candidate when there are other Republican candidates in the race. In this case, because Frank Ury entered the race, a Board vote was required for Mr. Ming to receive our endorsement. The club has run into these situations numerous times over the years, and we have sometimes voted to provide an endorsement in a contested race (Shawn Nelson comes to mind in a previous Supervisor’s race) and sometimes voted not to (DeYoung/Bates, Spitzer/Pauley, and a dozen other non-supervisor races). These decisions have always happened according to protocol – our own internal protocol, not ones dictated to us by the blogosphere. The process has barely ever involved candidates coming to speak to the club. There have been instances where that was deemed necessary or fruitful, but those instances are the exception, not the rule. Robert Ming was asked to leave the room while the Board discussed the proposed endorsement. Our board is not filled with political novices and ignoramuses. We know the candidates and have relationships with those whose candidacy we are asked to consider. Robert Ming is probably the easiest endorsement vote I have cast in my entire time as leader in the Lincoln Club. He is everything the club stands for: The epitome of fiscal responsibility, a devoted family man, a competent leader and business professional, a man of faith and conviction, and contra 99% of those you will ever see mentioned on a OC political blog, he is an astute and philosophically-inclined student of political thought. Our club would be blessed to have HIS endorsement of us. Robert has served in our committees for over a decade and as an elected leader in Laguna Niguel is very well-known to the club and its leadership.
Frank Ury may or may not be a number of the things that Matt Cunningham says he is. The point is that our club feels so strongly about the qualifications and abilities of Robert Ming that we unanimously voted to endorse him. Matt says that we were two votes short. Again, this misnomer could have been easily cleared up had Matt done any homework. Our bylaws require a 75% threshold for endorsement; in Robert’s case, we got 100%. To the extent that there were some absent board members at the meeting, we secured the votes of absent members after the fact (so as to leave no doubt about the board’s commitment to its chosen path). This is also very common in our history and practice.
The reality is that it is none of Matt’s business how we conduct our business. We are a private organization and are under no obligation to defend ourselves to him. Only Matt can speak to what his real agenda is here in this unjustified attack on the Lincoln Club. As a matter of defending our public record I have chosen to reply to clear up the blatant falsehoods uttered in his piece. We were faithful to our own bylaws, faithful to our own traditions, and in this case, took an action supported by every single board member present at the meeting (as well as the Executive Committee which met two days prior). Our actions amount to the vanilla task of endorsing a candidate we consider to be one of OC’s conservative stars.
The club is on solid footing in its endorsement of Robert Ming. All over the county the buzz is growing for Robert’s candidacy as his endorsements continue to mount. We are proud of this endorsement and hope all Orange County residents will look at what Robert stands for when they consider the options in this race.
I spent the recess trying to balance my time between meeting with constituents and preparing for my wedding. I hope no one missed the news, but I got engaged to Janniffer Grubisich last November, and on August 3, we both said “I do”. Janniffer was with me in Sacramento Monday, when we returned to session, and I was able to introduce her on the floor to my colleagues as my wife.
OC Political 